Friday, April 13, 2018

Unnatural Categories: In Defense of Barnhill and Martucci

I read the controversial article that Dr. Anne Barnhill and Dr. Jessica Martucci wrote in  Pediatrics Perspectives, problematizing the use of the word "natural" in breastfeeding promotion campaigns, and while I think that they oversimplify the variety of reasons why people would be skeptical or resistant around adhereing current vaccination regimes, their core argument is an important one.

Barnhill and Martucci write:
It makes sense that breastfeeding promotion would make appeals to the 'natural.; The resurgence in breastfeeding rates over roughly the past 4 decades is rooted in a history of women’s organized efforts during the 1950s and 1960s to redeem the value of feeding babies 'naturally' in the face of widespread medical support for formula feeding. Coupling nature with motherhood, however, can inadvertently support biologically deterministic arguments about the roles of men and women in the family (for example, that women should be the primary caretakers of children). Referencing the “natural” in breastfeeding promotion, then, may inadvertently endorse a controversial set of values about family life and gender roles, which would be ethically inappropriate. Invoking the “natural” is also imprecise because it lacks a clear definition."
Their point is not that breastfeeding is not beneficial,  or shouldn't be promoted, but that in identifying it as "natural" and assigning a moral value to that category we identify mothers and families who can't breastfeed -- women and other mothers who don't lactate,  men  and other fathers who are raising babies together or on their own -- as "unnatural" in ways that skirt dangerously close to the rhetoric of Christian fundamentalists and Trans-Exclusive Radical Feminists.    (If you aren't familiar with Judith Butler's questioning of the category of "natural woman" here is a taste -- http://magdor.tumblr.com/post/108754874029/when-aretha-franklin-sings-you-make-me-feel-like)

The problem with dismissing things as "unnatural" is that it quickly leads to dismissing people as "unnatural."  I am highly critical of the choices we in this culture make around technologies such as genetic engineering, petrochemical production, smartphones, and the methods of using and administering pharmaceuticals -- but I find that as soon as people move beyond the specifics of how the use of these technologies is impacting complex living systems and into the argument that they are "unnatural" they soon begin talking about the ways in which those technologies are allegedly responsible for the existence of monstrously unnatural people -- usually members of sexual and neurological minorities that have existed since the beginning of humanity and beyond. 

I am an animist -- I experience everything in the world as alive and conscious, and nothing as un-natural.  This includes things made by human technology.  I wish humans wouldn't dig up uranium and put it in nuclear reactors and produce plutonium -- but the plutonium humans produce is still part of the living world, just as much as Roses and Hummingbirds and waterfalls are, and only when we fully engage it can we begin to transform the systems that produce it and find ways to deal with the reality of its toxicity.

And sometimes the best and least disruptive interventions we can make to support someone's healing involve technologies and approaches we might otherwise be critical of which ultimately support the establishment of coherence and healthy flow in living systems in ways more efficient and less damaging than ostensibly more natural interventions.   As an herbalist, it is easier for me to support healthy tissue recovery after a surgery to remove a skin cancer than it is for me to do so after someone has applied a caustic "black salve."   Sometimes technologies we might otherwise be loathe to apply are the best means in a given situation to stabilize a person whose health is rapidly deteriorating so we can move forward with the real work of healing.

My teacher, Karina, repeated to me over and over again that "A witch works with all things"-- dismissing some of those things as "unnatural" can be an impediment to healing, magic. and justice.

33 comments:

Maggie Emm said...

Well said!

Jasmine Miller said...

Really i found this article more informative, thanks for sharing this article.
ashwagandha extact manufacturer in india

Gerry Dearie said...

kamagra gold reviews Read The Shocking Truth About

sofy grass said...

how many price of Tadagra Softgel 20mg usa

nataligrass said...

be aware form Cenforce FM 100mg side effect

Ruth Taylor said...

Thanks for sharing the additional information with us,
best weight loss supplement.

logo design services said...

Great post, you have pointed out some fantastic points , I likewise think this is a very wonderful website.
logo design services

maria berglund said...

how tazzle 10 works in pulmonary hypertension.

nataligrass said...

be aware from the femalegra side effects

strapcart02 said...

Buy Tazzel 20 FM uk with best price.

rose mary said...

let know yourself about silagra price in india

medy medypharma said...

know the difference between malegra vs viagra online

sarah lge said...

get some knowledge about vigora 50 mg side effects in hindi

Gerry Dearie said...

Vidalista 5mg buy online from usa

rose mary said...

is the zenegra for woman and children too?

helen brown said...

buy Kamagra Gold 100mg online price in usa

Buy Cenforce said...

list out the price of Megalis 10mg in india at online

Mary Kate said...

caverta 100mg price in usa is low

Nida Sara said...

what is the side effect of vilitra 10

monika watts said...

where to tadacip 20 mg wikipedia

Mary Susan said...

is tadarise 20 oral jelly very effective

medypharma51 said...

find out the fildena 50mg price at home from online

sarah lge said...

give such a useful suhagra force 50 mg review online at website

medy medypharma said...

Tadalista Professional effectively treats impotency

sarah lge said...

buy Duratia 30mg online with lowest price

Jackson Elizabeth said...

know the manufacturing of BigFun 100mg usa

Isum Medypharma said...

how many vidalista 20 mg dosage at per day

strapcart02 said...

know the Fildena 150mg price at online

rose mary said...

when to take Duratia 60 mg and why?

Buy Cenforce said...

Chewable ED Medicine is cenforce Soft online from india

Anonymous said...

Thank you for such a nice article. I am definitely going to share this article with my friends.
logo design company

roz an said...

Buy Tadarise 40mg Online is a name for generic Cialis, an erectile dysfunction medication based on Tadalafil. Know about tadarise 40 mg Reviews, uses, dosage, Price , How to take , Side Effect , How to use. cheap Tadarise 40 sunrise. Tadarise 40 for sale Online . Order Tadarise 40 Now !

Web Design said...

Here i have read your blog and its post related to the --- which is pretty impressive and good to know about it and you have done mind blowing work on this blog....keep doing well and keep updating with new post.